Search This Blog

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Buy Medical Insurance wisely (my personal experience)

Life has this amazing knack of playing roulette with you!

I had planned to write about my experiences with medical insurance on the first Sunday of this month, and a medical emergency on that Saturday itself took the entire weekend. And this Sunday was dominated by work.

Anyway, here goes. 6 points based on my experience of what to do – and what not to do – while buying medical insurance.

Buy what you need – not what saves you tax: We have this amazing thing in India of Rs.15,000 tax saving under section 80D (we all seem to remember this section, as we save the entire amount on tax). Hence, we all end up investing only this amount on Mediclaim. I did the same. But maybe it is not enough for some families. What if there are 3 children and aged parents to take care of? What if there is a medical history in the family that necessitates preparation through proper medical insurance planning? There are many possibilities. Always take into account all these factors while deciding how much to invest. Rs.15,000 should be the minimum, and not the only number. My own experience – my old policies had lapsed and I had to take a new policy in 2007. I realised that I would have to shell out a huge premium for my parent’s insurance, as they are both above 60, hence in consultation with them, we decided not to take insurance for them.


Over the next two years, both of them required treatment, and we had to shell out of our own pockets!

Do not let your policies lapse: The second lesson I learnt. I had mediclaim till 2004, which we allowed to lapse when I went abroad. It would have cost next to nothing to keep it alive, but I allowed it to lapse. Result – when I came back and invested once again, I had to pay higher premia as we had moved into different age brackets, and we also lost all no-claim benefits.

Buy a floating cover, it is worth the extra premium: The harshest lesson I learnt over the past one year. I have insurance for myself, my wife and both the children. On seeing the difference in premium, I decided to go in for separate policy amounts for each individual, insuring myself for the highest sum, followed by my wife, and then smaller amounts for the children. My daughter and I both needed hospitalisation this year. And while the amount for me was well within my insurance limits, the amount spent on my daughter’s treatment extended well beyond. This naturally took a huge chunk out of my savings. The funny part is – the total amount for both our treatments combined is less than 2/3rds of the total insured value for both of us. In other words, had I taken a floating cover, I would not have spent a rupee (apart from the minor amounts that insurance companies or their TPAs love to deduct).

Find out what insurance companies have tie-ups with good hospitals near your home: And go with only those companies which do. It is a simple but oft overlooked fact, but think about it. Where do we rush to in an emergency? The best hospital nearest to our house. And if at that time we have to also run around for money? It can get extremely harrowing. Believe me; we have been through it in the past year! Remember, it is not only for ourselves but also for our family members, who spend the best part of their day near home itself.

Find out who offers cashless treatment at a good hospital near your home: It follows from the previous point. You may get insurance, and everything may be in order, but if the hospital and the insurance agency do not have an agreement for cashless treatment, you could run around like a dog chasing its tail!

I had my accident on Sunday afternoon. Unfortunately, the hospital and my insurance company did not have a tie-up for cashless, and the hospital rules wanted us to pay Rs.1.4 lakhs for me to be operated upon immediately. And with my left hand broken (for those unaware, I am left-handed), I could not even sign a cheque. Even if I could, what use would it have been on a Sunday? It was only the emergency and possibly our family friend’s (who is a doctor known to the surgeon) discussion that made the hospital accept that they would do the surgery and we could make the payment the next day.

Everyone would not be as lucky!

Also, for me, claiming the money from the TPA was like getting money from a Jew! Have you heard of the saying “A fool can ask more questions than the wisest man can answer”. I am sure the person who coined this saying must have had to answer a doctor in an insurance company!

And the number of times they made me run around, I could qualify for the Olympics! They are expected to complete one process in 45 days, but you ask them about the claim on the 46th day, and then they will start sending queries. The way the lady at the TPA counter acted aghast when I asked her how come their letters don’t reach our house when every other letter does, had to be seen to be believed. I get a strong feeling they do this only to delay payments.

I nearly gave up on one claim because I realised that I may end up spending more than 20% on taxi fare going back and forth, in addition to the huge waste of time! And when I stopped responding, they sent the cheque home – one year later!

I learnt the advantage of cashless a while earlier when my brother had to be rushed to hospital at midnight, and everything was taken care of like clockwork.

Do not trust your insurance agent: Sound a bit harsh, but it is true. Remember, he is doing a job, which is to sell you a medical policy. He may end up saying yes to everything you say, with just the right pauses and intonations to drive you towards where he gets more commission.

Decide your requirements, read the fine print and make your own decision.

After all, it’s your life – and your family’s.

6 comments:

  1. Very well written at a time when I am planning something similar for my family too!
    Thanks a ton Mubin
    Btw, can I put up this post on my site too!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Getting Insurance for parents is even more difficult. I applied for Abba for an insurance which was slightly on the higher side, so the insurance company said they need to conduct some medical test. He went thru all the tests and then the company rejected his application saying they have identified "some issues". I tried following up with the company but they said "we do not disclose our test results".

    ReplyDelete
  3. mubin

    i had a turn around experience. last year, i had to take my son for an endoscopy. he is covered and cashless at a good hospital nearby. max to be precise. insurance is a corporate policy.

    once the hospital knew the corporate-ness of the policy, a room was needed (not necessary in the procedure, we were told later), a premium room billing was done for a really basic room with no space even for the person accompanying (5k for a room, equal to a few star hotel properties!), procedure performed next morning without adequate nourishment being planned for a 12 year old (it is a fasting procedure so a 12 year old was kept on fast from 6 am to about 3 pm; and even then all he got was a glass of juice because of a liquid diet - all this when i was paying a premium for a dietician), and more such pain points that i find almost funny now.

    the best part. at 4 the next afternoon, the bill read 19K (this was a sunday), as we got approval for cashless (we had made a deposit), the bill jumped from 19K (also because of the ease at which we got approvals) to, hold your breath, 29K in 3 hours. it became difficult to get approvals as the tpa had shut by the time. and the nurses refused to even remove the needles injected for sugar and liquid feed into him. absolutely disgusting experience. finally we managed, with some cash of us at 7.30 pm, and he got his first meal of the day at 9.30pm (he was to be given home food only).

    forget about medical insurance man. this country truly belongs to the dogs and the less said about services, the better.

    the same hospital, because of the same policy covering my parents also, decided to keep my dad under iccu observation for breathlessness at a cost of 30K while clearly he was just hypoglycemic and needed a sugar shot (chocolates worth 100 bucks or so). the heart doc made my mom think that if he is not in observation, we would need invasive surgery and an implant worth 6 lacs because of a weak pulse!

    so yea, medical insurance is necessary. but who is to police these rascals, who in the name of services are heel bent on looting. this is dacoity in plain sight, unfortunately we also end up being grateful for it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Every other institution to do with finance in this country are cheats. the only advantage of a medical insurance is psychological and works till you do not actually have a medical problem. It looks like a hopeless situation, till there are more litigations and they are held accountable nothing is going to change

    naseer

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Raj,

    Please do. No problems, if it helps someone

    ReplyDelete